Top 5 Lobster Rolls in Nantucket

Nantucket, with its idyllic beaches and rich maritime heritage, is renowned not only for its picturesque landscapes but also for its culinary delights. Among the island's most celebrated offerings is the quintessential lobster roll—a savory marriage of fresh, succulent lobster nestled in a buttery, toasted bun. Whether you're planning your first visit to Nantucket or a returning traveler, if you are wondering where to go to get the best lobster roll on the island, here are the top lobster rolls you definitely want to sink your teeth into!

1. Cru

Cru is a waterfront restaurant overlooking the harbor just steps from the highspeed ferry drop. Not only is Cru the hottest restaurant to get reservations at in Nantucket, but it is home to the most decadent lobster roll in all of New England! Topped with pickled onion and served in a buttery brioche bun, this lobster roll is served with fresh lobster in your choice of hot lemon butter or cold lemon mayo, but what elevates this lobster roll is the option to top it with a heaping mound of mouthwatering caviar. Each bite is like an explosion of flavor as briny ocean notes from the caviar complement the sweet, tender lobster meat, creating a luxurious indulgence that elevates this seaside favorite to new heights of culinary delight.

2. Queequeg’s

Located in the heart of town, Queequeg’s is a favorite of visitors and locals alike. This lobster roll is delicious with cold chunks of succulent lobster served in a chilled tarragon aioli and nestled in bib lettuce on a toasty buttery roll. This lobster roll is also garnished with a little cilantro which I thought complimented this roll perfectly. Don’t miss a chance to sit on the patio and watch the people walk through town while enjoying this delightful lobster roll!

3. Millie’s

Located in Madaket, Millie’s is a favorite of Nantucket locals and regulars, and is known for their mouthwatering lobster roll called the Muskeget. You can savor the simplicity of this classic New England style lobster roll: sweet chunks of lobster lightly tossed in mayo, nestled in a crisp bib lettuce leaf and garnished with finely chopped chives. Millie’s is about a 15 minute drive or 30 minute bike ride from town, but is definitely worth the trip!

4. Sandbar

Sandbar is stellar beach front restaurant located right on Jetties beach to the north of town. Sandbar is the perfect lunch spot when spending the day on one of the north shore beaches and their lobster roll is one of the best! Tender lobster meat is delicately tossed in lemon-infused mayo sitting atop a buttered brioche roll. The blend of sweet seafood and creamy citrus is complimented with an aromatic touch of fresh dill.

5. Walter’s Deli

Walter’s is a renowned delicatessen in the heart of town right next to the famous Juice Bar. The small deli is take out only, so it is a perfect place to stop in to get a luscious lobster roll to go. Savory chunks of lobster, dressed in creamy mayo, are tucked in a warm, buttery bun, offering a taste of seaside indulgence right in the heart of town. Whether you take this lobster roll to eat over looking the harbor for lunch or while watching the sunset on Steps Beach for dinner, this is another lobster roll that you won’t want to miss!

To plan your next Nantucket, check out my full travel guide on Nantucket here!

I hope you enjoyed this article. To receive updates new blog posts, follow me on Instagram at Blissfully Boarding. Link is below!